News article created on 16 May 2019

The fixed spool reel

Did you know?

Almost two thirds of households near our waterways are disadvantaged. Support our community projects along canals and rivers.

The autumn years of the Victorian era were synonymous with great inventors sporting radical new ideas in fishing tackle. The fixed spool reel era was in its embryo stages in the latter stages of the great empress’ reign.

The Illingworth no 1  reel The Illingworth no 1

Brass fixed spool reel

Peter Malloch, a fishing tackle dealer from Perth patented the first brass fixed spool spinning reel in 1884. Using a swivel foot principle, a conventional centrepin or rotating drum reel could be turned on a 90-degree axis allowing line to come off the top, thereby achieving greater distances. Its biggest drawback being that after the cast the reel had to be turned back to its original position on the rod.


The Malloch reel

This new reel provided the opportunity for “spinning” with dead baits, spoons etc. rather than using the accepted centrepin where much skill was needed to execute these techniques. The Malloch reel had just one more glitch. With greased cotton or silk, the line retrieved in the same direction every time, so it quickly became kinked to such an extent that it had to be taken off the spool and the kinks removed. Malloch countered this by introducing the “reversible” spool thus, in theory, the kinks could be removed automatically just by reversing the spool. It worked up to a point.

The “Malloch Casting Reel survived into the 1940s. As late as 1946 P Topsfield patented the “Adaptacast”, an add-on swivel foot gadget to convert a normal centrepin into a fixed spool 'style' casting reel, using the Malloch principle.

A H Illingworth

The Illingworth reel

The acknowledged inventor of the fixed spool reel is Alfred Holden Illingworth, a mill owner, who undertook to iron out the “kinks” of line twist that dogged the earlier Malloch. Like Malloch before him, Illingworth had the idea to let the line come of the top of the spool in a similar way to the wool strands on his factory bobbins.

Illingworth's contribution was the development of the bail arm to collect the line and lay it back on to the spool without the need to rotate the reel on the rod.

Champion performance

In 1905 the first “Illingworth Number One” was patented. Illingworth went on to win the International Bait Casting tournament in 1908 using a modified crank wind fly reel incorporating a cotton bobbin as the spool. Modifications by other anglers on Illingworth's original design specification were soon to follow. The revised bail pickup Illingworth Number 2, patented in 1910, became the first fixed spool reel of the shape and form we know today.

Bazley’s choice

The publicity surrounding Illingworth’s newly invented reel took the angling world by storm. Amongst its supporters and field testers were the Yorkshire match ace Jim Bazley and that great trout angler W Carter Platts. One contemporary report, from a Yorkshire newspaper dating from 1910, makes interesting reading:

Mr J. H. R. Bazley and the “Illingworth” Reel Win Again.

“Mr Bazley must be a bit of a terror to North Country anglers who fish in competitions! Armed with the “Illingworth” reel, which permits of a very light bait and float being cast almost any reasonable distance, he again beat 399 other anglers in the recent big competition on Bank Holiday. The match took place on the Swale near Skipton Bridge, and the winner was Mr. Bazley with 5lb. 1½ oz., the next Mr. Vernon, of Leeds, with 2lb. 11 3/4oz.' How many 400 peg matches do we see on the Swale today?


Chippendale reel

Other manufacturers soon copied the Illingworth design but Holdroyd Smith was ruled to have infringed Illingworth's patent rights. J E Miller of Leeds retailed the revised “Chippendale”, an engineering triumph with a compacted spool though it did not have a multiplying gear.

Bakelite spools

Inspired by these attempted improvements, Illingworth went on to improve his reel seeing the introduction of the No 3 in 1914 until the final improved bakelite spool No 5 appeared in 1937, some 12 years after Illingworth’s death. Throughout this time Illingworth “steadfastly refused to make any personal profit out of it. By this invention of the fixed spool reel he opened up a field of angling that has given untold pleasure to a great number of anglers.”

The Allcock Stanley

The Allcock Stanley reel

Designed in 1926 and later mass produced by the great Redditch firm of S Allcock & Co, later to become Shakespeare’s, our nations early favourite was the “Allcock-Stanley”. Costing just 25 shillings in 1930, which is the equivalent of around £75 today, it was more affordable than most fixed spool reels of the day. It was however an abomination to use.

First closed faced reel

Time moved on and the year 1930 saw Milwards introduce the ill-fated “Torpedo” reel (endorsed by Jim Bazley) which was in essence the first attempt at a closed face reel. Five years later, P W Felton designed his famous “Crosswind” reel, a clever improvement to oscillate the spool and lay the line evenly upon it. The second world war intervened in the progress of tackle development as most firms became involved in war engineering and munitions.

Post war progress

The post war years saw the rise of the famous Ambidex and Duco series sold under the J W Young and Allcocks names. Hardys, never out of the limelight, had been at the forefront of design in the more expensive stationary drum reels like the Hardex and Altex. They successfully patented the automatic full bail arm system in 1932 and were to prevent other manufacturers from using this feature until the mid 1950s.

Arrival of the Mitchells

The French firm of Carpano & Pons first introduced the first half-bail Mitchell (300) in 1948, a reel that was to capture the imagination of English anglers, land the record carp of Dick Walker in 1952, and as the “Mitchell Match” go on to help competitors win the National Angling Championships many times over. Perhaps the fixed spool reel of the last century or were the Abu closed face reels such as the 501, 506 and 507 even better? What do you think.

Mitchell half bail 2 Mitchell half bail 2

About this blog

Angling history

John Essex was a key member of the legendary Leicester Likely Lads match team of the 1970’s. He picked up five first division one national championship team medals and was third overall in the 1975 match on the Nene, landing two carp, which was a remarkable angling feat at that time. John coached the Leicester juniors to five NFA junior titles and chaired Leicestershire Angling Federation for nearly 30 years

Still fishing weekly at club level, John is an avid collector of books and old tackle with an extensive library of nearly 1000 books. He will be releasing his first book, 'History of the National' shortly. John blogs for us about angling history and heritage.

See more blogs from this author